A Boris Johnson Return: Tory Hopes And Fears

Laila Abdi

5 min read

Post on May 03, 2025

4.0

Share

The Hopes: Why Some Tories Still Back Johnson

A significant faction within the Conservative party still clings to the belief that a Boris Johnson return is the best, or even only, way to revitalize the party's flagging fortunes. This hope rests on several key pillars.

His Electoral Success

Johnson's undeniable electoral success remains a powerful argument for his supporters. His landslide victory in the 2019 general election delivered the Conservatives' largest majority since 1987.

• 2019 General Election Victory: A decisive win, securing a substantial parliamentary majority.
• Brexit Delivery: Despite the complexities, Johnson's government ultimately delivered on the promise of Brexit, a key factor for many voters.
• Appeal to Working-Class Voters: Johnson successfully connected with a segment of the electorate traditionally aligned with Labour, a feat often cited by his supporters.

Polling data from the immediate aftermath of his resignation still indicated a significant level of support amongst Conservative voters, suggesting a lingering belief in his electability. This “Johnson Factor,” as some call it, remains a potent force within the party.

Strong Leadership in Times of Crisis

Proponents of a Johnson return point to his perceived decisiveness and ability to navigate crises. While his handling of certain situations was controversial, his supporters emphasize his strength during challenging moments.

• Initial Brexit Negotiations: Despite the tumultuous nature of the process, Johnson secured a withdrawal agreement with the EU.
• COVID-19 Response: The initial vaccine rollout under his government was widely praised, although later aspects of the pandemic response drew criticism.
• Perceived Weakness of Current Leadership: Many within the party believe the current leadership lacks the decisiveness and strength needed to navigate the ongoing economic and political challenges.

This perceived strength is contrasted with the current perceived weakness within the party leadership, fueling the desire for a strong, decisive figure at the helm.

The "Johnson Factor" and Party Unity

A core argument for a Johnson return centers around the belief that only he can reunite the fractured Conservative party. The party is currently facing internal divisions on various policy issues, and some believe Johnson’s charisma and unique brand of leadership could bridge these divides.

• Appealing to Different Factions: Johnson’s broad appeal could potentially unify disparate wings of the party, from the Eurosceptic right to more moderate elements.
• Restoring Party Discipline: His presence might instill a greater sense of discipline and unity within the parliamentary party, potentially quelling internal dissent.
• Improved Public Perception (Potentially): A unified party, projecting strength and competence, could potentially improve the Conservative party’s image with the general public.

The Fears: Risks and Challenges of a Johnson Return

Despite the hopes held by some, a Boris Johnson return presents considerable risks and challenges for the Conservative party.

Damaged Reputation and Public Perception

The numerous scandals and controversies that dogged Johnson's premiership, most notably "Partygate," have severely damaged his public image.

• Partygate Scandal: The numerous breaches of lockdown rules within Downing Street led to widespread public anger and accusations of hypocrisy.
• Other Controversies: Various other scandals, from questions surrounding the funding of his flat refurbishment to accusations of misleading Parliament, further eroded public trust.
• Negative Polling Data: Consistent polling data reveals widespread public disapproval of Johnson and his leadership style.

The potential damage to the Conservative party's reputation from a Johnson return is a major concern for many. This could lead to significant electoral losses.

Policy Inconsistency and Lack of Long-Term Vision

Critics point to a perceived lack of long-term vision and policy consistency during Johnson's premiership. His decision-making was often criticized as impulsive and reactive.

• Policy U-turns: Examples include changes in approach to Brexit negotiations and environmental policies.
• Lack of Detailed Policy Proposals: Many argue that Johnson often lacked detailed policy proposals and relied on slogans and charisma.
• Long-Term Consequences: Critics warn that past policy inconsistencies could have long-term negative consequences for the country.

Potential for Further Internal Conflict

A Johnson return could reignite internal conflicts within the Conservative party, potentially leading to further instability and division.

• Opposition from Key Figures: Several prominent figures within the party openly opposed Johnson's leadership, and their opposition is likely to continue.
• Government Instability: Renewed internal conflict could destabilize the government and hinder its ability to effectively govern.
• Further Erosion of Public Trust: Open party conflict could further damage the party’s standing with the public.

Conclusion: A Boris Johnson Return: Weighing the Odds

The prospect of "A Boris Johnson Return" presents a complex and multifaceted dilemma for the Conservative party. While some hope his return could revitalize the party's electoral prospects and restore unity, significant risks remain. His damaged reputation, policy inconsistencies, and potential for further internal conflict pose considerable challenges. Ultimately, the decision of whether to welcome back Boris Johnson will involve weighing these competing hopes and fears, acknowledging the substantial uncertainties involved. What are your thoughts? Share your opinions on a Boris Johnson comeback, or the return of Boris Johnson, in the comments below or join the conversation on social media using #BorisJohnsonReturn.