Has The Sequel Earned Its Place? Evaluating A Website's Successor

Laila Abdi

5 min read

Post on May 06, 2025

4.4

Share

Analyzing Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) Post-Launch

The first step in evaluating your website's successor is analyzing its key performance indicators (KPIs) after launch. This involves comparing data from before and after the redesign to determine the impact of the changes.

Traffic Analysis: Comparing Old vs. New

Analyzing website traffic is crucial for understanding the overall reach of your new website. Key metrics include organic traffic (from search engines), referral traffic (from other websites), and direct traffic (users typing your URL directly). Using tools like Google Analytics, you can compare these metrics pre- and post-launch to identify any significant changes.

• Organic Traffic: Did the redesign improve your search engine rankings, leading to an increase in organic traffic?
• Referral Traffic: Are you seeing more referrals from partner websites or social media?
• Direct Traffic: Has the brand awareness improved, resulting in more users directly navigating to your website?
• Traffic Source Changes: A shift in traffic sources might indicate the success or failure of specific marketing strategies implemented with the redesign.

Understanding these changes will paint a clear picture of your website's reach and visibility after the relaunch. A significant drop in traffic warrants a deeper investigation into the potential causes.

Conversion Rate Optimization (CRO) Success

Conversion rates are a critical indicator of your website's effectiveness. A conversion is any desired action a user takes on your website, such as making a purchase, signing up for a newsletter, or filling out a contact form. Compare your conversion rates before and after the relaunch to see if the redesign positively impacted user engagement and goal completion.

• Pre- and Post-Launch Comparison: A significant increase signifies successful CRO implementation.
• Specific Conversion Point Analysis: Analyze conversions for individual goals to identify areas of strength and weakness.
• A/B Testing: A/B testing different design elements can help optimize your website for conversions.

Analyzing conversion rates provides valuable insights into how effectively the new website achieves its objectives.

User Engagement Metrics: Bounce Rate, Time on Site, Pages per Visit

User engagement metrics provide valuable insights into how users interact with your website. Key metrics include:

• Bounce Rate: A high bounce rate indicates users are leaving your site quickly after landing on a page. A lower bounce rate suggests improved content and user experience.
• Time on Site: Increased time on site suggests engaging content and improved navigation.
• Pages per Visit: More pages per visit indicates users are exploring your site thoroughly.

These metrics provide insights into user experience and the effectiveness of your content and navigation. By analyzing these, you can identify areas for improvement and optimize your website for increased engagement.

User Experience (UX) Evaluation: Did the Redesign Improve Usability?

A successful website redesign prioritizes user experience. Evaluating UX involves assessing how easily users can navigate the website, find information, and complete desired actions.

Qualitative Feedback: User Surveys and Interviews

Gathering qualitative feedback is essential to understand users' perceptions and experiences.

• User Surveys: Conduct online surveys to gather feedback on different aspects of the website.
• User Interviews: Conduct in-depth interviews with a select group of users to gain a deeper understanding of their experiences.
• Feedback Forms: Provide feedback forms on the website itself for immediate user input.

Analyzing user feedback helps identify areas for improvement and refine the design for optimal usability.

Quantitative Data: Heatmaps and Session Recordings

Quantitative data provides insights into user behavior on the website.

• Heatmaps: Visualize where users click, scroll, and interact on your pages.
• Session Recordings: Record user sessions to observe their behavior and identify pain points.
• Tools: Use tools like Hotjar or Crazy Egg to collect and analyze this data.

This data helps to understand user flow and identify areas where the website design can be improved.

Website Speed and Performance

Website speed is critical for both user experience and SEO. A slow-loading website leads to high bounce rates and negatively impacts user satisfaction.

• Google PageSpeed Insights: Use this tool to measure your website's loading speed and identify areas for improvement.
• Image Optimization: Optimize images to reduce file sizes.
• Caching: Implement caching to improve loading times.

Improving website speed is crucial for ensuring a positive user experience and improving SEO performance.

SEO Performance: Has the Website Maintained or Improved its Ranking?

SEO performance is another critical factor in evaluating a website's successor. Analyzing keyword rankings, backlinks, and technical SEO aspects reveals the redesign's impact on search engine visibility.

Keyword Ranking Changes

Monitor your website's keyword rankings before and after the redesign using tools like SEMrush or Ahrefs. Identify any significant ranking increases or decreases.

• Keyword Tracking: Regularly track the ranking of your target keywords.
• Rank Fluctuations: Analyze any significant fluctuations to understand their causes.

Tracking keyword rankings helps to assess the effectiveness of your SEO strategy post-redesign.

Backlink Profile Analysis

Analyze your backlink profile to see if the redesign has affected your backlinks.

• Backlink Monitoring: Use tools to monitor your backlinks and identify any lost or gained links.
• Backlink Quality: Assess the quality of your backlinks.

Maintaining or improving your backlink profile is crucial for SEO success.

Technical SEO Assessment

Conduct a technical SEO audit to identify any technical issues that may have arisen after the relaunch.

• Broken Links: Check for broken links using Google Search Console.
• Crawl Errors: Identify and fix any crawl errors hindering search engine crawlers from accessing your website.

Conclusion: Has Your Website's Successor Truly Earned its Place?

Evaluating a website's successor requires a thorough assessment of its KPIs, UX, and SEO performance. By analyzing these key aspects and comparing pre- and post-launch data, you can determine whether your investment has yielded the desired results. Remember to continuously monitor and improve your website's performance to ensure it's consistently earning its place. Ready to evaluate if your website's successor is truly delivering? Use this framework to assess its performance and ensure it's earning its place!