New York City FC Vs Toronto FC: Player Ratings Compared

Laila Abdi

4 min read

Post on May 15, 2025

4.5

Share

Attacking Prowess: A Comparison of Forwards and Midfielders

NYCFC Attacking Strengths

NYCFC's attacking prowess often hinges on the creative midfield play of Maxi Moralez and the clinical finishing of Valentin Castellanos. Their fluid attacking system, emphasizing quick passing and movement, creates numerous scoring opportunities.

• Maxi Moralez: Consistently receives high ratings from sources like WhoScored, averaging a 7.2 rating this season, showcasing his key passes and playmaking abilities.
• Valentin Castellanos: A prolific goalscorer, Castellanos boasts a higher goal-per-game ratio than many other MLS strikers, earning him an average rating of 7.5 on ESPN.
• Team Tactics: NYCFC's possession-based approach allows their attackers to receive the ball in advantageous positions, maximizing their scoring potential.

Toronto FC's Offensive Capabilities

Toronto FC's attacking game relies heavily on the individual brilliance of players like Lorenzo Insigne and Federico Bernardeschi. Their direct style and ability to create chances from individual plays can be highly effective.

• Lorenzo Insigne: Insigne's skillful dribbling and accurate crossing have resulted in consistently high ratings from various sources, often exceeding 7.0.
• Federico Bernardeschi: His ability to score from distance and create opportunities contributes significantly to Toronto FC's attack, earning him comparable ratings to Insigne.
• Team Tactics: Toronto FC's more direct, counter-attacking style relies on quick transitions and individual talent to unlock defenses.

Direct Comparison

While both teams possess talented attacking players, NYCFC’s collective performance, facilitated by their cohesive passing system, often translates to a higher volume of shots and scoring opportunities. Toronto FC, however, relies more on individual brilliance and counter-attacks, leading to potentially more high-impact plays. Based on recent average player ratings, NYCFC exhibits slightly higher overall attacking efficiency.

Defensive Solidity: Analyzing Defenders and Goalkeepers

NYCFC's Defensive Performance

NYCFC's defensive strength rests on the experience and leadership of players like Sean Johnson in goal and the solidity of their backline. Their organized approach and effective tackling minimize scoring chances for opponents.

• Sean Johnson: Johnson's shot-stopping abilities and overall command of the penalty area have earned him consistent high ratings and contribute to NYCFC's strong defensive record.
• Defensive Unit: The NYCFC back four, despite occasional vulnerabilities, generally provides a solid foundation, consistently making crucial interceptions and tackles.
• Defensive Weaknesses: Occasional lapses in concentration have resulted in conceded goals, suggesting room for improvement in their consistency.

Toronto FC's Defensive Prowess

Toronto FC's defensive performance has been more inconsistent. While individual players show flashes of brilliance, the overall unit sometimes struggles with maintaining shape and dealing with rapid attacks.

• Individual Strengths: Certain players demonstrate strong tackling abilities and defensive awareness, but lack consistent team-wide cohesion.
• Team Coordination: The team occasionally struggles to maintain defensive structure, resulting in gaps that opponents can exploit.
• Goalkeeping Consistency: While the goalkeeper shows moments of excellence, inconsistency in performance contributes to the team's defensive fragility.

Defensive Comparison

NYCFC demonstrates a more reliable defensive structure compared to Toronto FC. Their collective performance results in a lower goals-against average and consistently higher ratings for their defensive unit. Toronto FC's defense, while possessing individual talent, shows greater vulnerability due to inconsistencies and team coordination issues.

Overall Team Performance and Player Ratings Aggregates

Aggregating player ratings from WhoScored and ESPN reveals a slight advantage for NYCFC in overall player performance. However, player ratings alone don't fully capture the dynamics of team play. Factors like team cohesion, tactical flexibility, and momentum significantly influence match outcomes.

• Aggregate Ratings: While specific numbers vary depending on the source, NYCFC consistently displays a higher average rating across its starting lineup compared to Toronto FC.
• Beyond Ratings: Toronto FC's reliance on individual brilliance means that their overall performance fluctuates more dramatically based on individual player form. NYCFC’s more cohesive playing style leads to a more predictable and higher baseline performance.
• Superior Performance: Based on our analysis, NYCFC displays superior overall player performance, demonstrating both stronger attacking and defensive consistency.

Conclusion

This comparison of New York City FC vs Toronto FC player ratings highlights NYCFC's edge in both attacking and defensive performance based on recent data. While Toronto FC possesses individual stars capable of game-changing moments, NYCFC’s collective strength and consistent performance offer a more reliable approach. Their cohesive playing style results in higher overall player ratings and a more stable team dynamic.

What are your thoughts on this New York City FC vs Toronto FC player ratings comparison? Share your predictions for their next encounter in the comments below! Let the discussion about NYCFC and Toronto FC player ratings continue!