Tagliafico Blames Man United Players For Ten Hag's Struggles

Laila Abdi

5 min read

Post on May 23, 2025

4.5

Share

Nicolás Tagliafico, having played under Erik ten Hag at Ajax, has ignited a firestorm of debate by suggesting that Manchester United's players, not the manager, are primarily responsible for the club's inconsistent start to the season. His comments, which have rippled through the football world, raise crucial questions about the squad's commitment, Ten Hag's managerial capabilities, and the overall dynamics at Old Trafford. This article delves deep into Tagliafico's accusations, analyzing their validity and exploring the wider implications for Manchester United.

Tagliafico's Specific Accusations Against Man United Players

Tagliafico, known for his insightful assessments, didn't pull any punches in his criticism. While he didn't explicitly name names, his comments pointed towards a systemic issue within the Manchester United squad. His accusations broadly centered on:

• Lack of Tactical Discipline: Tagliafico implied that some players haven't fully grasped or consistently implemented Ten Hag's tactical instructions. This led to breakdowns in defense and a lack of cohesion in attack, particularly visible during crucial moments in matches. He subtly alluded to instances where players deviated from their assigned roles, disrupting the team's overall structure.
• Individual Errors: The former Ajax defender highlighted a pattern of individual errors costing Manchester United points. These mistakes, he suggested, weren't merely isolated incidents but indicative of a deeper problem with concentration and decision-making on the pitch.
• Insufficient Work Rate: Tagliafico hinted at a lack of consistent effort and commitment from certain players. He implied that the intensity and pressing game demanded by Ten Hag wasn't consistently being replicated across the squad. This, he argued, significantly hampered their ability to control games and dominate possession.
• Poor Attitude: While not explicitly stated, the overall tone of Tagliafico's comments suggested a potential issue with attitude and commitment among some members of the squad. This could manifest in a lack of accountability for mistakes or a reluctance to fully embrace Ten Hag's demanding style.

These accusations, though not directly tied to specific matches, seem to reflect observations from the team's overall performances throughout the season's opening months. Analyzing matches against teams like Brentford or Brighton, one can see instances where individual errors and tactical indiscipline cost Manchester United dearly.

Ten Hag's Managerial Style and Player Compatibility

Erik ten Hag's philosophy is built on possession-based football, high pressing, and intricate passing movements. This highly demanding style requires a specific player profile – technically gifted individuals with high intelligence, exceptional fitness, and unwavering discipline.

• Ajax vs. Manchester United: At Ajax, Ten Hag worked with players who were inherently familiar with his style, having been developed within the Ajax academy system. This fostered a seamless integration of his tactical demands. The Manchester United squad, on the other hand, comprises players with diverse backgrounds and playing styles, some potentially less suited to his intense and demanding approach.
• Clash of Styles: The transition hasn't been smooth, with some players seemingly struggling to adapt. The differences in approach and the need for a complete system overhaul are likely the root of the issues. This mismatch between Ten Hag's high-intensity demands and the existing players' capabilities and mentalities could be a key factor in the team's struggles.

Essentially, Ten Hag's methods, while successful at Ajax, might require a more significant squad overhaul to fully take effect at Manchester United.

The Impact of Tagliafico's Comments on Manchester United's Morale and Public Perception

Tagliafico's comments have understandably caused ripples within the Manchester United camp. Public criticism from a respected former player of Ten Hag can severely undermine team spirit and create internal divisions.

• Media Frenzy: The statement has dominated headlines, with various media outlets analyzing the claims and their potential validity. This constant scrutiny further adds to the pressure on the already struggling team.
• Public Opinion: Fans are divided, with some agreeing with Tagliafico's assessment and others defending the players. This polarization adds further pressure on the squad and the manager.
• Transfer Implications: The controversy could influence future transfer decisions. The club might prioritize players who better fit Ten Hag's style, potentially leading to significant squad changes in the upcoming transfer windows.

Football pundits have also weighed in, with some echoing Tagliafico's concerns and others highlighting the need for patience and time for Ten Hag's methods to fully take effect.

Alternative Perspectives and Counterarguments

While Tagliafico’s viewpoint holds weight, it’s essential to consider counterarguments.

• Injuries: Manchester United has suffered from significant injuries this season, disrupting squad stability and impacting team cohesion.
• Team Chemistry: Building a strong team spirit and chemistry takes time. The current squad's lack of cohesion could also be a factor independent of individual player performance or the manager's tactics.
• Fixture Congestion: The relentless schedule of Premier League football can also lead to fatigue and affect performance.

Other analysts have suggested that Ten Hag needs more time to implement his system fully. It's argued that judging his tenure based solely on the early part of the season is premature.

Conclusion

Nicolás Tagliafico’s accusations against the Manchester United players have ignited a heated debate. While his concerns regarding tactical discipline, individual errors, and potentially attitude issues are valid points, it’s crucial to consider the counterarguments concerning injuries, team chemistry, and the demanding schedule. The question remains: are the players or the manager primarily responsible for Manchester United's inconsistent form? Ultimately, a holistic approach is needed, acknowledging both the players' shortcomings and the manager’s adaptation challenges.

What do you think? Is Nicolás Tagliafico right to blame Man United players for Erik ten Hag's struggles? Share your thoughts in the comments below! Join the discussion on whether the players or the manager bear the brunt of responsibility for Manchester United's inconsistent form. Let's debate the #ManUnited #TenHag #Tagliafico controversy!