Post-Romulus: Choosing The Right Legacy Character For The Next Alien Movie

Laila Abdi

5 min read

Post on May 27, 2025

4.0

Share

Analyzing the Success of Previous Legacy Characters

The success of the Alien franchise hinges on its iconic protagonists. Understanding what made them work – and what didn’t – is crucial in selecting the next Alien Legacy Character.

Ellen Ripley's Enduring Impact

Ripley's enduring impact stems from a potent combination of factors:

• Resilience: She faced unimaginable horrors and survived, time and again, against overwhelming odds.
• Motherhood Instincts: Her protective instincts, initially towards Newt, expanded to encompass humanity's fight against the Xenomorphs.
• Relatable Fear: Despite her strength, Ripley's fear was palpable, making her a relatable character even in the face of terrifying extraterrestrial threats.
• Evolving Relationship with the Xenomorphs: Her confrontation with the Xenomorphs went beyond simple survival; it became a personal vendetta.
• Iconic Status: Ripley's image transcends the film series; she's a cultural icon representing strength and survival against the odds.

Ripley's success wasn't just about her actions; it was about her humanity. She was an "everywoman" thrust into extraordinary circumstances, making her triumphs and fears all the more compelling. This relatability, coupled with her unwavering determination, is the gold standard for any future Alien Legacy Character.

The Faltering Attempts of Newt and Hicks

While Newt and Hicks were compelling characters in Aliens, their potential as legacy characters remained largely untapped:

• Newt's Vulnerability: While endearing, Newt's vulnerability limited her potential as a leading figure in subsequent films.
• Hicks's Bravery: Hicks embodied bravery and resilience, but his limited screen time prevented him from developing into a fully realized legacy character.
• Underdeveloped Character Arcs: Both characters lacked the extensive character development that propelled Ripley's story across multiple films.

The failure of Newt and Hicks to fully capture the essence of an Alien protagonist highlights the challenges of building on established characters without overshadowing the original. Their stories underscored the need for a more complete and compelling narrative arc for any potential successor.

Amanda Ripley's Unsuccessful Inheritance

Amanda Ripley, the cloned daughter in Alien: Resurrection, unfortunately failed to resonate with audiences:

• Genetic Connection: While her genetic link to Ripley was a compelling premise, it ultimately felt insufficient to support her character.
• Strained Relationship with the Ripley Legacy: Amanda struggled to escape the shadow of her mother, hindering her ability to forge her own identity.
• Failure to Resonate with Audiences: Her character lacked the depth and complexity that made Ripley so iconic.
• Issues with Alien: Resurrection: The film itself was widely considered a departure from the darker, more suspenseful tone of the earlier installments.

Amanda's failure showcases the pitfalls of relying solely on lineage. A successful Alien Legacy Character needs more than just a genetic connection; they need a compelling narrative of their own.

Potential Candidates for the Next Alien Legacy Character

Several avenues exist for choosing the next face of the Alien franchise.

Exploring New Bloodlines

Introducing a new character related to a significant existing character offers intriguing possibilities:

• Grandchild of Hicks or a Distant Relative of Ripley: This approach allows for both familiarity and fresh storytelling.
• Potential for Fresh Storytelling: A new relative could explore themes of legacy, inheritance, and the enduring impact of the Xenomorph threat.
• Risk of Overshadowing Established Characters: This approach risks failing if the new character is merely a pale imitation of their predecessor.

Carefully crafting this new character’s backstory and motivations is essential to avoid simply repeating past successes.

Reimagining Existing Characters

The possibility of resurrecting a seemingly dead character offers unique creative opportunities:

• Bringing Back a Seemingly Deceased Character: A character from Alien 3 or Alien: Resurrection could be revisited with a new perspective.
• Challenges of Resurrecting a Character: Doing so requires careful consideration to avoid undermining the original narrative.
• Creative Opportunities: Resurrection can offer fresh interpretations and deeper exploration of existing characters.

A Completely New Protagonist

The most daring option involves creating an entirely original character:

• Freedom of Creating an Original Character: This path grants maximum creative freedom.
• Potential to Establish a New Direction: An original protagonist could reinvent the franchise's thematic focus.
• Challenge of Generating Audience Connection: A new character must quickly build a connection with the audience to be successful.

A compelling origin story and immediate stakes are crucial for this strategy's success.

Essential Qualities of a Successful Alien Legacy Character

Regardless of their background, a successful Alien Legacy Character must possess certain key qualities:

Resilience and Determination

Facing unimaginable horrors, the next protagonist must demonstrate unwavering resilience and an unyielding determination to survive. This strength of character, akin to Ripley's, is paramount.

Relatability and Vulnerability

Despite facing terrifying circumstances, the audience must connect with the character on an emotional level. Vulnerability alongside strength creates a relatable and compelling hero.

A Compelling Arc

The character must undergo a significant transformation throughout the film, experiencing growth and development that resonate with viewers. Their journey must be meaningful and memorable.

Conclusion

The search for the perfect Alien legacy character is crucial to the franchise's future. While no one can fully replace Ellen Ripley, choosing the right successor—one who embodies resilience, relatability, and a compelling arc—is paramount. Whether it's a new character, a reimagined old one, or a fresh take on a familiar lineage, the next Alien movie must deliver a protagonist worthy of the legacy. Let's keep the discussion going – who do you think should be the next Alien Legacy Character? Share your thoughts in the comments!